ok to our resident comic book men. I need advice im going to read the frank Miller Batman books. But i need a good X men book preferably one I already know the stories of or am at least familiar with the charters. Would the Dark Phoenix saga be a good place to start or how can I find the Weapon X stories
im going to let pucket handle this but i will say and trade paperback you can find of astonishing xmen should be great i was also a fan of uncanny xforce
As far as Miller Batman goes, just read Year One and Dark Knight Returns.
X-Men ... sigh. There's a few ways to do this. The cheapest is grabbing the X-Men phone books (the Essential series) but they're on crappy paper and there's no color.
You could pick up the omnibus of the original X-Men which runs $100 or so but is huge (around 1k pages IIRC). You could grab any of the Claremont omnibus editions (around the same price), but some knowledge of X-Men comics/history helps when reading them.
To me, what it ultimately boils down to is what you want in an X-Men book and how much you know about X-Men continuity and characters already, and how much confusion you're willing to tolerate (i.e. do you care how certain characters started dating, or are you willing to simply accept that they are?).
Joss Whedon's run on Astonishing X-Men (and let's be specific about the writer Borst, because the stuff after Joss wasn't as awesome) is fantastic.
Grant Morrison's run on X-Men (New X-Men IIRC) was great.
I'd steer away from more current X-Men titles because there are a fair number and the writing is occasionally dull/convoluted, and the most enjoyable one for me is Wolverine And The X-Men, but it's much more in the vein of Wolverine running the school and the hijinks and hilarity (and action and conspiracies and such) that result.
So - without knowing more, the only two X-Men books I can recommend without really hesitating are Whedon and Morrison's work, but Morrison's work requires a bit more knowledge of the X-Men world than Whedon's does.
Clear as mud? Good. And see how I did this without really giving out any spoilers?
***EDIT***
Don't forget http://www.instocktrades.com/default.aspx - I looked up one of the Claremont/Lee omnibus editions and it was discounted 42% so you're only paying $72 and change instead of $150.
Last edited: