The Logitech keyboard you're thinking of is the G15, not the G5. The G5 is a Logitech mouse, that I actually recommend over the Razer, especially if this guy has normal/big hands. The Razer seems very tiny and breakable, the G5 is larger and feels more sturdy. The G15 is a nice keyboard with the LCD panel. I don't think you need to go that far though, and you'll be just fine with a Saitek Eclipse. They are nice keyboards.