Can't say for sure, though I don't think it matters that much. You'll get the best opinion if anyone happens to own one.
gives you more information on the product, while the other one doesn't.
personally, it wouldnt matter to me - I doubt the quality is that drastically different if you compare the two together.
If you don't like one, return it to Newegg, then get the other one. You have a 1 year warranty with them.
If you keep going through a few headsets in a while, you should invest your $$$ on a good headset that'll last you a long time. It just makes sense.