But yesterday DNA results revealed in London's High Court proved that elfin-faced Alfie did not father the girl by Chantelle.
Instead, Maisie is the daughter of fellow schoolboy Tyler, who was 14 when Chantelle fell pregnant.
It is said that Tyler is now intending to care for the three-month-old baby in the future.
The Sun pictured 4ft Alfie with Maisie and Chantelle in February. The schoolboy believed he'd become Britain's youngest dad, saying: "When my mum found out I thought I'd be in trouble.