If we're comparing kernels here then we can say it's all just improved from XP really.
Then we might as well go back farther say it's improved off of Win2k/NT
Hell, NT was an improvement on DOS based systems.
Still though, going by all of my customers reactions (and other enthusiasts internet wide) to WIndows 8 it's not just Metro that they don't like and that is a simple fact. Just look at the market share and reception to Windows 8 compared to 7.
That's because people got ****y that the start menu was removed and that they introduced Metro UI - your customers, enthusiasts, etc. Plus, the people that are posting are the ones complaining - not many people post about something when it's working just right - just like ALL products.
If it was as simple as installing a start menu it wouldn't carry such negativity. And actually this will be proven once 8.2 is out and circling around. Simply adding the start menu back won't change that people don't like 8.
The majority of the negativity is carried by non-power users, because they ARE the majority. They don't know you can just install an extra piece of software to get the Start Menu back. Plus, if you actually look, you'll see just as many people saying Win8 is great and that the Start Menu isn't needed as there are people saying Win8 sucks for not having a start menu.
I have had only a few issues on all the Win8 systems I've worked on - and all of them were driver related. That is NOT a Windows issue, that is a DRIVER manufacturer issue. Windows is not responsible for that.
Win8 is getting a bad rap like Vista did. Vista was unpolished (hell, it was fairly bad - I'll agree to that) when it first released - after SP1 and SP2 though it worked. Then they improved upon that with Win7. And honestly I never had issues with Vista - I thought it was a huge improvement over XP in several areas (specifically networking / file & folder sharing). So, just like Vista, Win8 is getting a bad rap still even after updates that made it run very well. And really there isn't a difference that you'll notice right away between Win7 and Win8 besides the few UI changes. Most of the changes were under the hood, and were beneficial to the system.
But I know you'll just say (like usual when this topic is brought up and I post about it) "no reason to defend an OS if it's really good" so it's a bit like talking to a brick wall with you sometimes
.