Hmm, this one is the one I have and is decent. If you have SATA however this one might be better, Maxtors are cheaper but I have had my share or problems so you could go WD or Seagate if you have the money but theres been many threads about which is better and never a clear winner, although I think I will be going Seagate for my next drives. Also I bought OEM drives which are cheaper but more difficult to return and have a much weaker warranty and no box or documentation if you need it.