I'd say get the Intel Motherboard, simply because it would probably be better tailored to supporting your Intel Penitum 4 Processor- as Intel made it themselves.
However, there isn't anything wrong with buying Motherboards from other manufacturers. There are many other motherboard manufacturers, many reliable such as ASUSTeK and MSI (there are more I can't remember!
). They are all tailor made to fit specific specifications, and can be different. So it's not necessarily that a brand specific board purchased to couple with the same brand component will operate any better. There are other motherboards out there which will do the job just as great, maybe even better. Motherboards are really made to fit a certain type of user, and a certain type of Processor.
As long as you are happy with the specifications, then you're good to go.