Ok, this turned out to be a bigger problem than it should have been. I followed the webpage diagram for both cable select and slave, unfortunately the hard drive is such a tight fit that the jumpers are too big, and the hard drive will not go back into its proper place in the laptop
Not sure who's brilliant idea that was. I have no idea where to get smaller jumpers, I just took one off an old motherboard I had.
I was able to get cable select in properly, but nothing changed, I still get the same blue screen and reboot. When I have it in slave, I get a "Non-system disk or disk error" which I can't tell if its because theres something wrong with it being slave or if the jumper is preventing the hard drive from being secured properly since I would get that same error if no hard drive was installed.