Only hard-drives I've ever owned were seagate. I own two of the seagate 1tb 7200.11's right now. great drives. Fast, so quiet I can't hear them and so far, stable and reliable.
It's just personal preference I guess, but unless something big happens, I'll never trust anyone but seagate :/
People seem to like the WD though.
I don't know about any of the seagate reviews 'cause i've never had to bother reading any, but until one fails on me personally I won't be switching
And I trust newegg reviews about as much as I would trust a convicted thief to house-sit for me.
If you're that worried over it, just go with WD or samsung. They're both great drives apparently.
If anything you'll have peace of mind, and a great HD.