okay, how about this, Top Ten Reviews gave out the following as a list of the "best" antivirus programs you can have, as based on West Coast Labs Tests .
AntiVirus Software Review 2009 - TopTenREVIEWS
1. BitDefender
2. Kaspersky
3. Webroot
4. G DATA
5. ESET NOD32
6. Paretologic
7. AVG
8. Vipre
9. F-Secure
10. Trend Micro
Similarly, PC World's List of Security Suites (AV plus firewall and other stuff) goes like, as based on AV-TEST.org's results:
Chart - Top Internet Security Suites - PC World
1. Norton/Symantec IS
2. BitDefender IS
3. Panda IS
4. McAfee IS
5. Avira PS
6. Kaspersky IS
7. F-Secure
8. Webroot
9. Trend Micro
Whatever list you may want to believe, AVs rated by AVC are graded, not ranked with results like these:
In no particular order
ADVANCED Detection: Kaspersky, BitDefender, ESET, AVAST, AVIRA, and some other lesser known AVs
Surprisingly, crowd favorite AVG only scored STANDARD...
Personally, I use BitDefender Total Security, since it is one of the best AVs according to reviews, works real good in my experience, and I feel secure using it.
But from your given choices, and from my own opinion, get Kaspersky AV, and partner it with a real good firewall...Also, when you meant hardcore evidence, it would be difficult considering that independent labs have different zoos for testing...