I hear what you are saying on this one. To be fair, I'm just finishing chapter 7; so still have a ways to go before making my final decision. I played Arkham City last week and feel like that is probably the better game, thus far. Storyline is definitely picking up, though.
Actually, out of curiosity, what game do you think deserves a 10?
Reviews are based off the genre they are in. For it's genre, you could give it a 10. I haven't played it yet, but yeah, it is more likely a 9.5 or something. Usually they only give half a point higher than gspot, not a whole one. IGN gave GTA IV a 10, but I would only give it an 8 because I don't like it.
i jus got uncharted 2... its pretty neat very overrated tho.. i cant imagine uncharted online gameplay.. as its mostly about walking around dangerous situations with touch sensitive missions... ie: don't get spotted or w/e