This is a good thread, I must say! Everyone is acting very mature, no flaimg or anything and that really says something about the Tech Forums community!
Anyways, I would have to say that I do enjoy gaming on my PC more than on my consoles if it is just me playing. On the other hand my consoles are awesome for party gaming, like when friends come over and want to have some fun or whatever.
Ultimately, the console is pretty much always going to have a broader appeal than PC's of course because of the pricing and the huge variety of gaming offered. But PC gaming gives a whole more serious perspective (to me) to gaming because I feel more secluded and more like I am in the gaming with both arms and fingers spread wide and operating so quickly and simultaneously.
That's my spill on it all...take it for what it's worth (probably not much).
::-Chase-::