Thanks apokalipse, I ordered just the fan...the Sunon 40x40x10 cause that's the same size as the one I took off. I was also going to order a couple LED fans, but those things are 10 bucks a piece if you only buy 2. So I went with the plain black Masscool that was 1.39 a piece for 15....my case fits 8 fans so I don't think I'll be worrying about temps after I install those. Might even mod my case a little to accept another fan or two. Thanks everyone for your help, I think I'm all set.
You guys are a friendly bunch, I think you'll be hearing more problems from me in the future.