And finally -- Do I even have a legitimate reason to go with Water Cooling?
I'm running core i7 920 revision d0, I have X58 SLI LE motherboard.
I bought a coolermaster v8, but it's already too late to RMA it, and the fan is already going out and there is something wrong with it, as I'm idoling at around 44C.
I also wish to overclock up to 3.8 GHz or more, but hopefully staying within a safe limit. I figured I'd need water cooling for this.
And finally, I am building this for my senior project at school. It needs to be the coolest ever, and I figured this would be a really nice addition.
Are those good enough reasons, or anything I should think about other than those?
you really only need water cooling if you are going to be doing some extreme OC'ing, or want a more silent PC.
that kit i linked you to will easily give you headroom for 3.8... i have my i7 at 4.1ghz and temps are great; <60C load. as for staying in a safe limit, you dont really need watercooling. a lapped TRUE120 would probably be fine for up to around 4ghz
you are building the computer, or setting up the water cooling for you senior project? i think if you really want it, and are fine with spending $300 on it, go for it! but be warned... it is very addicting. i started with a $150 setup, and have now dumped around $400 (probably more) on water cooling, lol