I always try to look at the cost of the replacement cartrige.
Those printers look like they're fine, but the replacement cartridge is $81.
If the initial cost of the printer is $234 (After rebate), and a replacment toner cartrige is $81, that is almost 35% of the cost! that's a hefty price. I guess it depends on how much you plan to use the printer.
For me, i just buy a cheap printer, use it till it runs out of ink and go get another one. $40 for the whole printer with cartriges, OR $45 for replacement cartriges...